Finding those comparable titles

I’ve been neglecting my blog of late. That’s not because my publishing success has gone to my head, or I’ve been too busy with my social life. Rather, it’s because I’ve been busy trying to get some writing done before I leave to enjoy the beautiful landscapes and cultural delights of Scotland, for which I leave tomorrow.
[See image at the end of the post for more info]

Firstly, I’m relieved to report that I managed to finish the substantial developmental edit on my novel. 🙂 It took me a little longer than I anticipated (doesn’t it always?) but writing ‘The End’ on it this time around was just as anti-climatic as the very first time it happened. Only, this time, I know that everything that I’ve written has a clear and focused reason for being there and all the major characters are fleshed out, as are the major plot points. There might be a couple of minor things to fix in the next round, but I’m confident it won’t take any major rewriting; which is a huge relief.

New books – Yay!

As a reward for getting through those edits – and as a sneaky method to do some research – I ordered myself a selection of new books to read (one of which was an e-book). Some of these were intended for my week long trip North of the border, but I indulged in two of them pretty much straight away. Partly because I love books and as soon as I have a new one in my hand I have to read it – NOW! – and also because I wanted to see if my suspicions were correct and I could stop panicking about an element of my novel-writing that’s had me puzzled for far too long.

So, after a (very) long, drawn out thinking process I’ve finally realised that the genre that best represents my novel would be contemporary mystery. I never intended to start out writing a novel with mystery elements in it, but the antagonist – Madeline – is most certainly a mysterious character and it’s up to my protagonist – Chris – to find out more about her and her life. Over the past few months I have tried to compare my story to novels with similar themes and I was wandering around book stores actively searching for ‘books about secrets’. Now, it feels like I’ve just been missing the most obvious thing in the world by not making the connection there with the mystery genre, but at the time it just didn’t click. Not until I re-read ‘The Husband’s Secret‘ by Liane Moriarty and thought to myself: This is it, this is exactly the type of book I’m writing and how she makes me feel as a reader is just how I want people to  go away feeling after reading my book. 

Well, when I realised this and went to investigate what genre the book was things just kind of fell into place. So I’m now investing in comparable titles to find other contemporary mysteries and acknowledging that this is the type of book I’ve actually written myself. What’s great about it is that I get to read lots of new books. What’s more challenging is that I’ve probably set myself up for an ambitious, lofty goal – having a comparable author like Liane Moriaty whose other books I’ve really enjoyed (What Alice Forgot Little Lies I’ve both read), but it’s so nice to finally feel I’ve written something suitable for an actual market; even if potentially it has to compete with such amazing novels such as the ones I’m reading! In a way, that just makes me more determined to craft the best novel possible; because now I know what my goal is.

It feels so great to be able to go on my holiday and know that one of the big worries of my novel – not knowing where it fit in the market – is mostly solved. It will make it much easier to find agents to submit to and to explain in my query. And, the more I read in the genre – the more comparable titles I find – the more I can see my own novel sitting side by side on the shelf with them.

Had I not rewarded myself by investing in reading time after finishing this stage of my writing project I might still be wondering about my novel’s genre and worrying about where it would fit. But now, in my next pass, I can review the words with this style in mind and see if it lives up to expectations. Not only that, but it feels like my holiday to Scotland is extra well-deserved because in the last two weeks I’ve also written two short stories for competition submission for which I’ve received some really lovely feedback from my writing group.

Things feel good here, and I wanted to share that. It’s been three years in the making, this novel, and in the last few weeks I feel like it’s moved along in leaps and bounds – not just as a physical manuscript but also in my approach and thinking of it. Finding comparable titles can sometimes be a huge challenge if you simply write the book you want to read and then it turns out to be nothing like you’ve ever read before. But don’t give up; keep reading, keep taking things in and, eventually, it’ll all slot into place.

Finally, just to make you all jealous: this is where I will be spending the week – Kenmore, Loch Tay


3 responses to “Finding those comparable titles

  1. Congrats on finishing the edit! I knew you could do it. Also, congrats on figuring out your novel’s place in the broad spectrum of writing genres. Now to get it polished into the shiny gem it was always supposed to be.

  2. You said it beautifully, Cat: “This is it, this is exactly the type of book I’m writing and how she makes me feel as a reader is just how I want people to go away feeling after reading my book.” That’s exactly how I settled on my comp titles-when I finally hit on the books that gave me a particular reading experience, made me feel a certain way-the way I hope my readers will feel-I knew I’d found the answer to the nagging question of comparables. Congratulations on breaking through! And enjoy your holiday.

    • Thanks doll! Will be devouring as many comp titles as I can and enjoying it! It’s eluded me so long so it feels amazing to find some finally! As you say, it’s more about the feeling than the content of the story sometimes.
      Thanks for stopping by to read and comment.
      Take care, Cat

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s